Enjoyable classic-style movement with additions that do not all improve the adventure
Sonic Superstars gives me enough enjoyable two-dimensional Sonic to keep the overall reaction positive, but its new ideas do not come together as strongly as I want. Running, jumping and using the different characters can feel good, and the Northstar Islands give the adventure a bright new setting. The trouble is the uneven pace around that foundation. Boss encounters can take the energy out of a stage, Emerald Powers vary in how useful or satisfying they feel and the cooperative idea is not automatically a comfortable fit for fast movement. Six and a half is my score. I enjoy parts of the adventure and appreciate the attempt to build something new around the classic format. I do not find the complete game consistently lively enough for a stronger recommendation. Its best moments show how much appeal the familiar movement still has, while the weaker additions make me wish the package trusted that appeal more.
The basic stage action is the strongest part. A two-dimensional Sonic game needs its jumps, slopes and routes to make movement enjoyable, and Superstars has sections where those elements connect well. I like finding a line that carries the character forward without making the whole level feel like an automatic ride. The game also has room to slow down and look for another route, which gives the scenery a purpose beyond being passed at speed. My reservation is that the quality of that flow is not equally consistent across the adventure. A useful stretch of momentum can be followed by something that feels less comfortable or more restrictive. I do not need every stage to have the same pace, but I want the change to feel worthwhile. The stronger sections make the controls feel familiar in a good way. The weaker ones make the structure around those controls more noticeable than the pleasure of moving through it.

The four main characters give that structure some useful alternatives. Tails' flight, Knuckles' gliding and climbing, Amy's hammer and Sonic's movement each create a different way to read a situation. I like having a practical reason to choose someone beyond a preferred appearance. A route can become more inviting when a character has a clear way to reach or cross it, and another run can reveal something missed by the first approach. The game benefits from that established variety. The limitation is that a choice of character cannot make every section equally enjoyable. Some demands remain awkward or slow regardless of the ability available, and the adventure does not always feel as though its routes are making the most of the cast. I enjoy the potential and several of its uses without finding that the full package consistently delivers on them. The characters help the experience, but they are not enough to carry every uneven decision in the surrounding stages.
Emerald Powers are the main new attempt to broaden the action. Abilities that create duplicates, change movement or reveal another possibility can give the player more options than a familiar jump and spin. I like the intention to make collecting Emeralds affect ordinary play instead of only a distant final reward. The problem is how unevenly those powers fit into the rhythm I enjoy. An ability can be visually striking and still feel less satisfying than handling the section through the character's regular movement. Some uses create an interesting alternative, while others feel more like a way to bypass a problem than a better way to play through it. That is not automatically bad, but it weakens the appeal for me. I want a new tool to make a stage more enjoyable, not simply make it possible to avoid the part that is less enjoyable. The powers add variety without consistently making the underlying platforming stronger.
The bosses are where the pace most often loses me. A stage can build momentum and then arrive at an encounter whose repeated patterns and limited opportunities make progress feel much slower. I like a boss that asks for observation and gives a clear opening in return. I am less enthusiastic when the waiting becomes more noticeable than the act of responding to the attack. The colorful presentation and character of the enemies help the first impression, but the repetition of an encounter has to be enjoyable on its own. Superstars is not consistently convincing there. The issue is not simply that a boss is more demanding than the stage before it. It is that the demand can feel drawn out in a way that weakens the energy the stage has established. Those interruptions are important because they sit on the main route through the adventure, making the complete journey feel less lively than its stronger platforming stretches suggest.

Local cooperative play is an appealing idea because the cast already has distinct abilities and a clear sense of personality. I like the possibility of sharing a stage rather than restricting the characters to separate attempts. Fast platforming also creates a difficult practical problem for that idea: keeping everyone comfortable inside a shared view while different people want to move at different speeds. The format has to make cooperation feel like a useful way to play instead of a competing demand on the camera and pace. I do not think the presence of the option automatically proves that balance has been solved. The game has a welcoming visual style and plenty of energy, but the cooperative ambition can expose how carefully a Sonic stage depends on the movement of the person controlling it. I appreciate the addition as a choice, while finding the solo platforming a clearer reason to value the package than the promise of a larger group on screen.
I finish Superstars liking enough of the movement and character variety to keep the score positive, while remaining disappointed by the consistency of the whole adventure. The new setting and colorful presentation give it an identity, and there are enjoyable routes that make familiar Sonic actions feel worth returning to. Emerald Powers, boss pacing and the demands of shared-screen play are much less convincing. Six and a half out of ten reflects a game with a worthwhile core that does not receive equally strong support from every addition around it. I do not need a modern classic-style Sonic to avoid new ideas. I want those ideas to make the ordinary act of playing more satisfying. Here some create welcome possibilities and others interrupt the rhythm I most enjoy. The result is entertaining in parts, but not the confident, consistently flowing adventure its strongest sections make me hope for.
Final thoughts
Superstars has enjoyable classic-style movement and useful character variety, but its additions are uneven. Emerald Powers do not always improve the platforming, bosses can drain the pace and shared-screen play introduces its own demands. I like the foundation more consistently than the complete adventure. 6.5/10.
Final score: 6.5/10.
Reviewed on PC. A review copy was provided by SEGA.

Sonic Dash 2 Sonic Boom Review
SONIC PICO PARK Review
Sonic Rumble Review