An attractive island adventure that keeps putting chores between me and its better stages

Sonic Rush Adventure gives the Rush formula a much larger frame, and I do not think that frame consistently improves it. The islands, ships and nautical setting make the game feel like a distinct journey rather than a simple second set of stages. I like the atmosphere and the return of Blaze, and some of the platforming has the lively pace the premise needs. The problem is how often reaching that platforming involves another trip, another material requirement or another repeated task. Five out of ten is my score. I can enjoy sections of the game without finding the whole adventure satisfying. The additions make it broader, but breadth is not automatically a benefit when the new material slows down the part I am most interested in. I want the island journey to make the action more exciting, and too often it feels like something placed between the stages and me instead of something that strengthens them.

The main platforming keeps the boost and trick relationship from Rush. Performing actions can replenish the gauge that supports another burst of speed, so a jump has a role in the next stretch rather than being entirely separate from it. I like that idea when the stage gives it room to flow. A route can become more enjoyable through understanding how its ramps, enemies and transitions connect. My reservation remains the balance between pace and readability. Moving quickly is fun when the next demand is communicated clearly enough to react to or learn from. It is less fun when the next interruption feels abrupt. The game has enjoyable sections, but I do not find that quality consistent enough to make the ordinary acts a strong recommendation on their own. The surrounding adventure then asks those uneven stages to provide materials and repeated visits, which makes the difference between a good stretch and an irritating one more noticeable.

Sonic Rush Adventure game imagery 1

The sea travel is the biggest change. Drawing a route on the chart and using different ships to reach another island gives the DS hardware a clear purpose outside the action stages. I like the sense of choosing a destination and actually traveling toward it instead of selecting a level from an anonymous list. The limitation is repetition. A travel activity can be entertaining as a change of rhythm and much less appealing when it becomes another required step before the next stage. Different vessels vary the input, but they do not make every trip equally interesting. I find the island idea more convincing as atmosphere than as something I want to carry out every time the progression demands it. The game wants the journey between destinations to matter. I would rather those journeys be shorter or more selective, allowing the better ones to provide variety without making the whole structure feel stretched around them.

The material requirements make that structure more frustrating. Building ships and equipment gives the stage rewards a practical purpose, and I can understand the appeal of connecting successful runs to a growing set of travel options. The problem is the repeated work needed when the next requirement has not been met. I want another run to feel inviting because the stage is enjoyable or because there is a route worth improving. I am much less interested when the main reason is that the adventure needs another quantity of a resource before allowing its next step. That kind of progression can make a short game feel longer without making it feel richer. It does not mean every repeated act is worthless. The stronger stages can still be fun to revisit. I simply do not like the way the system makes repetition part of continuing the story regardless of how appealing that particular return happens to be.

The hidden islands and optional challenges give exploration something worthwhile to offer, but they also add another layer to a game already full of separate demands. I like discovering that the chart contains more than the most obvious route to the next main destination. A small island can provide a focused challenge and make the nautical setting feel more substantial. The Emerald pursuits also use different activities rather than placing every reward behind the same kind of bonus stage. I can appreciate that variety without enjoying the full set equally. Another race, special mission or collecting demand needs to be appealing in practice, not merely different from the previous one. Rush Adventure often feels as though it has several reasonable ideas competing for time rather than a confident sense of which ones make the journey most enjoyable. I would prefer a tighter selection of stronger activities over a larger structure that keeps extending the distance between the highlights.

Sonic Rush Adventure game imagery 2

The setting and cast do a lot to make the game appealing despite those reservations. Marine gives the island adventure a recognizable new presence, while Sonic, Tails and Blaze fit the voyage naturally enough that the nautical theme feels like more than a random backdrop. I like the colorful locations and the sense that the journey has somewhere different to go. The presentation makes the game more inviting than its resource demands and repeated travel would suggest. The bosses can also provide a larger endpoint to a location, though I do not find every encounter equally satisfying. Their scale is easier to appreciate than the rhythm of some of the actual fights. This is a recurring pattern in my reaction: the idea and appearance make me want to enjoy the next section more than its actual demands allow. The game has personality, but personality cannot make every required trip or repeated run an entertaining use of the same adventure.

I finish Rush Adventure at five out of ten because the expansion of the formula creates as many reservations as attractions for me. The islands give the game an identity, the cast is appealing and some of the main stages have an enjoyable rhythm. The material requirements, repeated sea travel and uneven action keep preventing that rhythm from becoming the character of the full journey. I do not need a Sonic adventure to consist only of consecutive acts. I do need the additional systems to be worth the time they take away from the stronger stages. Here I too often want to get past an activity rather than look forward to it. The result is a mixed DS game with an attractive setting and useful ideas, but too much work between its more enjoyable moments. I can appreciate the ambition to make Rush broader while still finding the complete adventure less fun than that ambition promises.

Final thoughts

The island setting, cast and occasional strong stage make Rush Adventure appealing in parts. Repeated travel, material requirements and uneven platforming turn too much of the journey into work between highlights. I like the nautical idea more than the full structure built around it. 5/10.

Final score: 5/10.

Reviewed on Nintendo DS. No review copy was provided.