Wonderful music and clever shortcuts keep a slippery little racer worth a look

Sonic R has enough personality to make me forgive some of its awkwardness, but not enough to make that awkwardness disappear. Racing on foot is a good fit for Sonic, and the branching courses give the idea more to offer than simply running around a standard circuit. I like looking for a shortcut, deciding where to spend rings and figuring out how a character's ability might change the route. The problem is how slippery the act of steering can feel. A good plan needs a comfortable way to carry it out, and too often the movement gets in the way of enjoying the line I want to take. The soundtrack does a remarkable amount to keep the mood upbeat, while the small selection of courses puts a clear limit on how much there is to discover. I land at six and a half. It is an unusual, charming racer with worthwhile ideas, but its best qualities regularly have to work around the handling rather than benefit from it.

The courses are more interesting when treated as places to investigate than as lanes to follow unquestioningly. Rings can pay for doors that open alternative routes, and accelerators provide another way to spend the supply in exchange for speed. I like having to weigh a possible advantage against the cost of reaching it. A line that looks fast is not necessarily the only worthwhile route, especially when another part of the course contains something needed for an unlock. That makes learning the layout feel useful beyond merely memorizing the next corner. The problem is keeping that route planning enjoyable once the race is moving. The controls do not give me the confidence I want when making a quick adjustment, so an interesting shortcut can feel more fussy than exciting to use. I still enjoy discovering what the track allows. I just wish the moment of turning that knowledge into a clean run were consistently as satisfying as the discovery itself.

Sonic R game imagery 1

Character abilities help give the branching design a practical reason to exist. Tails can fly, Knuckles can glide and Sonic has his familiar speed-focused appeal, so the cast is more than a row of cosmetic choices. The game also mixes running characters with Amy's car and Eggman's vehicle, making the starting field immediately odd in a way I find entertaining. I enjoy a racing game willing to look a little ridiculous. The differences are most appealing when they suggest another way across a course rather than only changing how quickly a straight section ends. They cannot fully overcome my reservations about steering, and the stronger characters do not automatically make the roster feel evenly useful. Still, the selection gives the game an identity. Unlocking another racer is an attractive reward because the newcomer belongs to this particular strange little competition. The different ways of crossing water make the same stretch of track worth examining with another racer, which is a useful incentive to experiment beyond the obvious fastest choice. I find the cast charming even when I am less convinced by the detailed balance or the feel of every character on the track.

Collecting the hidden items adds an enjoyable complication to simply finishing first. The Chaos Emeralds and Sonic Tokens give a race another purpose, but the result still matters: wandering away from the main route is not enough if the run ends without the required winning finish. I like that tension between exploration and maintaining a competitive pace. It encourages a better understanding of the layout and creates a reason to think about which detour belongs in which attempt. The tokens can lead to challenges against unlockable characters, giving the collecting a concrete payoff beyond filling a screen. My reservation is how much work this structure asks a small number of courses to do. Once the interesting routes have been understood, there is not a large new set waiting to extend the discovery. The unlocks make the available tracks more useful, but they cannot replace the excitement of arriving at an entirely new course with its own possibilities and obstacles.

The music is one of the strongest reasons this game stays in my mind. The bright vocal tracks give the races a confidence and warmth that I enjoy even when the handling is irritating me. I like how fully the soundtrack commits to that mood instead of acting like discreet background accompaniment. The colorful settings support it, making the whole thing feel cheerful rather than overly concerned with looking like a serious motorsport event. That presentation is not a minor bonus for me; it changes how willing I am to return to a game with obvious shortcomings. The alternative Time Attack activities also give the courses some additional use, including reversing direction and taking on objectives beyond the ordinary race. I appreciate those options, but they remain variations around the same limited foundation. The music makes another attempt more appealing. It does not create a new circuit, and it cannot make a reluctant turn suddenly feel as precise as I want.

Sonic R game imagery 2

My final opinion is warmer than the controls alone would suggest, and less enthusiastic than the soundtrack might make it sound. Sonic R gives its small courses interesting branches, makes rings useful as a racing resource and turns collecting into a meaningful part of unlocking the cast. Those ideas give me real reasons to enjoy it. The slippery handling is a persistent obstacle, and the limited course selection means the game runs out of discoveries before its presentation runs out of charm. I do not see it as a hidden masterpiece or a completely worthless experiment. It is a mixed racer with an unmistakable personality, and I enjoy parts of it enough to recommend a curious look rather than an eager commitment. Six and a half out of ten fits that position. I like what it tries to do with Sonic's movement and the spaces around it, but I wish racing through those spaces felt as good as listening to their music and uncovering their secrets.

Final thoughts

Branching courses, ring-funded shortcuts and enjoyable unlocks give Sonic R more personality than a basic circuit racer. The wonderful soundtrack helps enormously, but slippery handling and a small track selection keep the recommendation qualified. I like its ideas more consistently than its handling. 6.5/10.

Final score: 6.5/10.

Reviewed on Sega Saturn. No review copy was provided.