A more generous classic collection whose new characters matter more than its longer game list
Sonic Origins Plus is a stronger package because its additions give the classic games more than one useful reason to be revisited. Amy changes the way familiar stages are approached, Knuckles gains a place in Sonic CD and the Game Gear selection broadens the history represented by the collection. I like that the expansion affects actual play instead of relying entirely on another menu of artwork. Eight out of ten is my score. The excellent main adventures remain the foundation, and the added material makes the package more appealing without making every part equally valuable. The handheld games vary considerably in quality, while some of the reservations around the original collection's presentation remain. I recommend the overall experience strongly enough, especially for the character additions, but I would not treat a larger list as proof that the package has become completely comprehensive or uniformly excellent. It is a good collection made meaningfully more generous.
The central adventures still do most of the work. Sonic, Sonic 2, Sonic CD and Sonic 3 & Knuckles offer distinct rhythms and stage ideas, giving the package more substance than several nearly identical games would provide. I enjoy having those approaches together, from the first game's more measured movement to the larger journey and character variety of the later entries. Anniversary Mode makes them comfortable to return to through its broader presentation and more forgiving structure, while Classic Mode preserves another set of rules for someone who prefers that pressure. I like that the collection gives the player a choice rather than silently assuming the newer approach is the only worthwhile one. These are strong games in their own right, which is why the compilation remains easy to enjoy even when the surrounding decisions are less convincing. The expansion improves the package because it adds to an already worthwhile foundation rather than attempting to rescue an empty one.

Amy is the most appealing addition for me. A new playable character should change how a level is read, and her hammer-based actions give familiar situations another set of possibilities. I like returning to a stage because the available tools suggest a different approach, not merely because the portrait beside the life or coin display has changed. The addition also gives the cast a more complete presence inside these adventures rather than leaving Amy mainly outside the ordinary play. That is a meaningful way to revisit classic material. It does not turn every old stage into a completely new game, and it should not need to. The value is in the smaller changes that make a familiar route worth examining again. I find those changes more useful than another decorative feature around the same unchanged selection. The collection benefits most when the expansion creates another reason to enjoy the actual platforming, and Amy does that.
Knuckles in Sonic CD provides another worthwhile change of perspective. Gliding and climbing alter the way a space can be investigated, giving the game's exploratory side another practical fit. I like that the character's abilities can make a familiar wall or gap suggest another route rather than simply reduce the time needed to reach the same endpoint. CD already has a distinct identity through its level structure and time-related goals, so another way to move through that structure is a sensible addition. The same qualification applies as with Amy: a new character does not automatically make every section equally comfortable or equally exciting. The original layouts still have their own priorities. What matters is whether the option creates enough interesting differences to be worth choosing. Here I find that it does, making the package feel more generous through a playable variation rather than only through another number attached to its contents.
The Game Gear games broaden the selection considerably. I appreciate having the handheld side represented because it contains different experiments and a different scale of platforming, not simply smaller copies of the same console games. It gives the collection a more interesting range to inspect. The quality is uneven, though, and I do not think every added title deserves the same enthusiasm as the strongest main adventures. Some are enjoyable curiosities, some are worthwhile games and others mainly make the history more complete. That distinction is important when judging the package. A large number of inclusions can be useful without every inclusion becoming a reason to stay for a long time. I like having the choice, while recognizing that the real value of the handheld additions depends on which ones a player actually wants to return to. They make Plus broader, but the character additions are the clearer reason I find it better.

The missions, Museum and other supporting options remain useful ways to approach the central games. A short challenge can make a familiar action worth improving, while artwork and music give another reason to look around the package between attempts. I like those additions most when they support the games rather than make collecting rewards feel like another obligation. The coin system's help with repeated special-stage attempts is also a practical benefit, keeping the optional pursuit more approachable. My reservation is that the collection still does not feel equally thoughtful in every part of its presentation. The strong games can make those details easy to overlook, but they remain part of the package being recommended. Plus improves the amount and variety of playable material more clearly than it transforms the whole surrounding experience. I appreciate the improvements without wanting to inflate them into a claim that every reservation about the original release has disappeared.
I finish Origins Plus at eight because the expansion makes the collection meaningfully more attractive. The central adventures remain excellent, Amy gives familiar stages a useful new approach and Knuckles adds another worthwhile reason to revisit CD. The Game Gear games broaden the history even when their individual quality varies. Those are real benefits, not merely decorative extras. The package still has room to present its material more consistently, and a longer selection does not make every included game equally enjoyable. I recommend it for the strong combination rather than for an exaggerated idea of completeness. The best additions bring attention back to the platforming, which is where a classic collection should earn its value. Eight out of ten reflects a good package that has become more generous in ways that matter, while leaving enough unevenness that I would still separate enthusiasm for its strongest games from praise for every part of the collection around them.
Final thoughts
Amy and Knuckles in CD give the classic platforming worthwhile new approaches, while the Game Gear titles broaden the collection. Their uneven quality and remaining presentation reservations keep the praise measured, but Plus is a meaningfully more generous package built around excellent games. 8/10.
Final score: 8/10.
Reviewed on PC. No review copy was provided.
Sonic Origins Review
Sonic Dash 2 Sonic Boom Review
Sonic Mega Collection Plus Review