A generous classic library made more useful by saving anywhere, despite tedious unlocks
Sonic Mega Collection Plus is a collection I find easy to recommend because its best games remain excellent and the additions make the package more useful. On PS2, the Genesis platformers sit beside Game Gear releases and a substantial amount of archive material. I like having those different scales of Sonic together rather than being limited to one narrow definition of the series. The mid-game saving is the improvement that matters most to how comfortably the collection can be used. The less appealing decisions are still there, especially the awkward unlock structure and a few features that make access slower than it needs to be. Eight and a half is my score. The package is generous and full of worthwhile games, but I would not confuse generosity with flawless presentation. I enjoy the contents enough to work around the inconveniences, while still wishing a collection built around access were more straightforward about providing that access.
The Genesis games provide the strongest foundation. Sonic the Hedgehog, Sonic 2, Sonic 3 and Sonic & Knuckles are not interchangeable adventures, and I like being able to move between their different rhythms in the same package. The lock-on combinations are an important part of that selection. Sonic 3 & Knuckles belongs here as a complete experience, and the other combinations preserve useful parts of what those original releases could do together. A collection is better when it respects those connections instead of treating every title as an isolated icon. Plus gets that important point right. The spinoffs also give the package some variety beyond ordinary platforming. I do not like every one equally, but their presence makes the selection more representative and gives a shorter or less conventional game a place beside the strongest adventures. The value comes from being able to choose, rather than from pretending that every included title deserves the same praise.

The six Game Gear additions are a useful expansion because they show another side of the series rather than only increasing the visible total. A handheld Sonic has different space, pacing and presentation to work with, and I enjoy seeing those approaches alongside the larger console games. Some of these smaller releases are much more appealing to me than others. That unevenness is not a reason to exclude the whole handheld side from a collection. It is a reason to explore it with realistic expectations. I like having a package that lets a strong portable platformer and a stranger experiment coexist without making either one the sole purchase decision. The limitation is that more games do not automatically mean a proportionate increase in things I want to replay. A few entries are interesting to inspect rather than especially enjoyable to stay with. The Genesis highlights still carry most of my lasting enthusiasm.
Mid-game saving makes the package considerably more comfortable. Being able to stop a run and return later suits a collection whose games were not all designed around the same modern habits. I like an option that makes the original material easier to fit into an ordinary stretch of play without requiring the games themselves to be redesigned. It does not change why a stage is enjoyable, but it changes how easily that enjoyment can be reached again. The size toggle is another practical addition, especially for the handheld titles. These are the kinds of features I value in a compilation because they serve the actual act of playing. A large gallery can be interesting, but a useful way to save progress affects almost every visit to the collection. Plus feels stronger when it concentrates on those straightforward conveniences, giving old games a more accommodating wrapper instead of asking their age to explain every unnecessary inconvenience.
The unlock system is where that sensible approach breaks down. Repeatedly launching games to make other contents available is tedious, and I do not find it a rewarding substitute for a proper challenge. I want to start a title because it is the one I feel like playing, not because the menu needs another count before allowing something else. The hints have a similarly awkward time-based requirement. Helpful information is more useful when it can be reached when needed, rather than after the software has spent enough time running. These decisions make the package feel unnecessarily guarded about material it should be eager to share. They do not remove the quality of a good Sonic game once it is available, but they make the collection around that game less pleasant. The actual contents are strong enough that the release does not need these artificial reasons to keep returning to the menu.

The archive material is much more welcome. Manuals help preserve the way the games originally explained themselves, while artwork and comic-cover galleries give the characters a broader context than a list of titles can provide. I enjoy having that material available beside the games. The Sonic Heroes production images are an interesting extension into the later part of the series, even though they are supporting material rather than another playable attraction. The collection still has boundaries. Sonic CD and Chaotix are not part of this selection, so it does not gather every important early Sonic release simply because the name sounds broad. I can acknowledge that without weakening the strong recommendation for what is actually included. The package does not need an exaggerated claim of completeness. Its main games, handheld additions and practical saving feature already provide enough substance to make it worthwhile, while the galleries add another reason to look around.
I rate Mega Collection Plus highly because the useful additions strengthen an already good library. The Genesis platformers remain the main attraction, the Game Gear releases add a different perspective and saving during play makes the package easier to enjoy on ordinary terms. The awkward unlock conditions are a clear flaw, and the quality of the individual games is uneven. Those qualifications do not outweigh the amount of worthwhile material available. Eight and a half out of ten fits the complete PS2 package. I like it as a way to play and explore Sonic's earlier years, with enough variety to make another visit attractive for more than one favorite. I would simply prefer the collection to trust that quality instead of making access to parts of it depend on repetitive menu behavior. There is plenty to enjoy here without turning the process of opening a game into another task to work through first.
Final thoughts
Plus pairs the strongest Genesis Sonic games with useful handheld additions and mid-game saving that makes a real difference. The archive is worthwhile, while launch-count unlocks and time-gated hints are needlessly awkward. I still find the overall PS2 collection generous and very easy to recommend. 8.5/10.
Final score: 8.5/10.
Reviewed on PlayStation 2. No review copy was provided.

Sonic Mega Collection Review
Mega Man X Legacy Collection 1 + 2 Review
Mega Man X Legacy Collection 2 Review