A huge adventure whose broken rhythm overwhelms almost everything worth liking

Sonic the Hedgehog from 2006 has ideas I want to enjoy, but the finished game makes enjoying them far too difficult. The scale, music and ambition suggest a substantial new adventure, with three main characters and a world meant to connect their stories. The ordinary experience is dominated by awkward movement, unreliable interactions, long interruptions and a structure that keeps asking for patience without giving enough pleasure back. Two out of ten is my score. I can find individual things to appreciate without finding the complete PS3 game good. A promising stage or an attractive piece of scenery does not cancel the work required to move through the weaker material around it. The disappointment is not that the game tries something large. It is that so much of the basic interaction fails to support that ambition, leaving the next obstacle too often connected to the game's execution rather than an enjoyable challenge within its world.

Sonic's speed stages show the appeal and the failure most clearly. A large environment gives the movement an exciting setting, and the faster sections can create an immediate impression of scale. I like the idea of a route that sends Sonic through a dramatic location rather than a small corridor. The problem is how uncomfortable the control and collision can become when that speed needs to interact with the scenery. A jump should be something to judge and carry out, not something whose result feels uncertain because the game is handling the surrounding surfaces poorly. The camera adds to that discomfort when the view is less useful than the pace requires. I do not need every section to be easy. I need difficulty to come from readable demands and dependable actions. Too much of this game makes the ordinary process of moving feel like another problem to manage before the actual stage can become enjoyable.

Sonic the Hedgehog 2006 game imagery 1

The faster running sections are especially revealing because they put so much weight on anticipation and correction. Their spectacle can be appealing, but the interaction leaves little room for the kind of comfortable adjustment I want. I find the result more tense in an irritating way than exciting in a satisfying one. A fast Sonic stage works when a better understanding of the route lets the movement become cleaner and more expressive. Here a familiar section can still feel awkward because understanding the destination is not the same as having a comfortable way to reach it. The game repeatedly asks the presentation to carry moments the controls have not earned. I can admire an environment or enjoy the idea of a set piece while disliking the actual task of guiding Sonic through it. That separation between the visual promise and the play is one of the main reasons the adventure feels so disappointing rather than merely uneven.

Shadow and Silver broaden the package without fixing its foundation. Shadow's combat and vehicles give his campaign another emphasis, while Silver's telekinesis changes the basic activity much more substantially. I like the possibility of using objects and enemy attacks as tools, because it gives Silver a purpose beyond being another fast character. The slower pace and repeated demands make that idea less enjoyable than it sounds. Different abilities can create variety, but variety is not a substitute for making each style comfortable and engaging. The campaigns also revisit familiar environments, so the change of character does not always feel like a fresh adventure. It can feel like another route through the same rough edges. I do not think every character should play exactly like Sonic. I think each alternative should provide a strong reason to welcome the change, and this game too often offers another set of frustrations alongside the new ability.

The hubs and side tasks make the pacing worse. A connected town could have given the adventure a useful sense of place, but moving between the story, a small mission and the next stage involves too much interruption. The loading is particularly damaging because it sits around activities that are not interesting enough to justify the delay. I do not want to feel that starting and ending a small task takes a disproportionate amount of patience compared with the task itself. The upgrades provide a reason to earn money and continue through the structure, but a progression system cannot make a weak activity engaging simply by attaching a required purchase to it. I enjoy the intention of a larger world much more than the repeated practical steps needed to continue through it. The game keeps presenting another reason to stop when its best chance of becoming enjoyable would be to let a strong stage carry the action forward with fewer obstacles around it.

Sonic the Hedgehog 2006 game imagery 2

The music is one of the few qualities I can praise without much hesitation. It gives the environments an identity and often suggests a more exciting adventure than the one being played. I like the confidence of the soundtrack and the visual ideas behind several locations. The story is much harder to defend. Its dramatic scale, human setting and different character viewpoints do not settle into a consistently convincing whole, and the rough delivery makes the serious moments less effective. I do not think a Sonic story has to avoid ambition or emotion. I want those ambitions supported by a coherent adventure and presentation that makes the characters worth following. Here the interrupted pacing and uneven execution weaken the story before its ideas have much room to work. The music can make a moment feel important, but it cannot make the surrounding interaction or the larger narrative earn that feeling on its own.

I rate Sonic 2006 two out of ten because its failures are too central to work around comfortably. The attractive locations, strong music and occasional glimpse of a good action sequence show why the project could have been exciting. They do not make the movement dependable, the campaigns consistently enjoyable or the loading-heavy structure less exhausting. I find the game much more frustrating than rewarding, and the size of the package only gives those weaknesses more room to repeat. I would rather have a smaller adventure that handles its basic actions well than this ambitious one that keeps struggling with them. This is not a recommendation hidden under a list of qualifications. It is a poor game with a few worthwhile qualities trapped inside an experience that regularly gets in their way. The potential is visible, but potential is not what makes the next jump, mission or repeated stretch enjoyable, and the finished PS3 release falls far short of that standard.

Final thoughts

Strong music and ambitious locations cannot rescue the awkward controls, collision problems, loading-heavy pacing and uneven campaigns. I can see the game it wanted to become, but the finished PS3 adventure is overwhelmingly frustrating to play. The occasional good idea is nowhere near enough. 2/10.

Final score: 2/10.

Reviewed on PlayStation 3. No review copy was provided.