An appealing collection of Sonic's stranger outings, with a very uneven set of attractions

Sonic Gems Collection is more interesting to me as a gathering of unusual games than as a package in which everything is equally good. Sonic CD, Sonic R and Sonic the Fighters give the collection three very different personalities immediately. I like having that variety available together, especially when the point is to explore parts of the series outside the most familiar Genesis platformers. The handheld titles and museum add more reasons to look around, but they also make the unevenness of the selection clearer. Seven out of ten is my score. There is enough enjoyable and distinctive material to recommend the package, with clear qualifications about how much of it I actually want to revisit. The collection's appeal comes from giving these different games a place together, not from turning each of them into a masterpiece. I enjoy the curiosity it encourages, while still wishing the overall set of playable attractions were more consistently strong.

Sonic CD is the strongest reason for me to care about the main selection. Its time-travel structure gives the stages another purpose beyond reaching the end, and the different versions of a location encourage paying attention to the environment. I like a collection that gives this kind of unusual platforming a prominent place rather than hiding it behind a larger count of conventional titles. It brings a substantial adventure with an identity of its own. The value of including it is not only historical. There is an actual game worth exploring, with routes and goals that make another attempt meaningful. That matters because a compilation can become too interested in explaining why a title is rare and not interested enough in whether it is still appealing to play. CD gives Gems a strong playable foundation. It is the part of the collection I can recommend with the fewest qualifications about curiosity doing more work than enjoyment.

Sonic Gems Collection game imagery 1

Sonic R provides a completely different kind of attraction. Running around branching courses, finding hidden items and using rings to access routes gives the racing more to consider than simply following the most obvious road. I enjoy the unusual structure and the music, even though the handling and small course selection keep my enthusiasm measured. Its presence makes sense in a collection like this because it adds a distinctive activity rather than another variation of the same platformer. It also shows the limit of judging the package by variety alone. A different kind of game can still have substantial weaknesses, and a compilation does not remove them by placing it beside stronger material. I like being able to choose R when its particular mood is appealing. I do not find it strong enough to carry the entire package on its own. Here it works best as one worthwhile, imperfect part of a broader selection.

Sonic the Fighters is the most immediately playful of the central games. The exaggerated attacks and the cast give the fights a clear character, while the barrier system provides more to consider than the cartoon appearance first suggests. I like how differently it uses the same familiar faces. Amy's hammer and the other recognizable actions belong naturally in the fighting format, making the game more than a costume change around anonymous moves. My reservation is that I find its short bursts of combat more appealing than the idea of treating it as an endlessly absorbing fighter. That still makes it a useful inclusion. Gems is stronger because the three main titles ask for different kinds of attention, allowing a platforming adventure, a racer and a fighter to coexist without pretending they are the same kind of experience. The differences give the collection a genuine purpose, even when my recommendation for each individual game would vary.

The Game Gear side broadens the package again, but its quality is more mixed. I like seeing these smaller and stranger releases represented because they show how much the series experimented beyond the main console adventures. I do not think every experiment is especially enjoyable. Some handheld entries are worth a substantial amount of attention, while others are more interesting to inspect briefly than to keep playing. Having them together makes that distinction easier to explore without requiring each one to justify a separate purchase. The important qualification is that the count of included games is not the same as the count of games I want to return to regularly. A collection can be generous and uneven at the same time. Gems fits that description. The handheld selection adds context and variety, but the strongest part of my recommendation still rests on the central games and the pleasure of choosing between their different styles.

Sonic Gems Collection game imagery 2

The museum and original instructions are useful supporting features. I enjoy artwork and other archive material when they sit beside something worth playing, and the manuals help the games explain their original rules instead of relying entirely on familiarity. The practical save options for the emulated material are also welcome. They make returning to a smaller title more comfortable without requiring its basic design to be changed. The package has regional differences, so I would not treat every extra game listed for one edition as a promise about another. That does not weaken the central identity of this PS2 collection. It does make the actual contents more important than an exaggerated impression of completeness. I am happiest with Gems when it is simply making its unusual games accessible, with enough supporting material to make looking through them enjoyable. The slower unlock and hint requirements are less appealing because access is the very thing a compilation should be making easy.

I rate Gems Collection seven out of ten because it is worthwhile without being consistently excellent. Sonic CD gives it a strong center, while R and the Fighters provide distinct, enjoyable alternatives with their own limitations. The handheld games and museum make the package broader, though not every addition carries the same value. I like that this collection exists to gather material that would otherwise be less convenient to approach together. I simply do not want that useful purpose to turn into automatic praise for every included release. The best way to enjoy it is to explore, find the parts that appeal and accept that some of the experiments are much stronger than others. That is enough for a positive recommendation from me. It is a distinctive Sonic collection whose appeal is real, even if the uneven quality and awkward access to some extras keep it below the strongest compilation packages.

Final thoughts

CD, R and the Fighters give Gems three distinctive reasons to play, while the handheld releases and museum add worthwhile context. The quality varies substantially and some access requirements are awkward, but the central selection makes this a good collection of Sonic's less conventional games. 7/10.

Final score: 7/10.

Reviewed on PlayStation 2. No review copy was provided.