A colorful adventure with good ideas that the remaster does not make equally convincing
Sonic Colors Ultimate is enjoyable because the central adventure still has a strong identity. An enormous amusement park in space is a wonderful setting for Sonic, and the Wisps give the stages more to do than simply alternate between running and jumping. I like the variety of movement and the way a new power can make a familiar section worth inspecting again. My enthusiasm is more qualified when I consider the complete package. The stages vary in pace and appeal, some Wisp interruptions are more enjoyable than others and the remaster's additions do not make every part of the adventure stronger. Seven out of ten feels right. I recommend it for the colorful settings and the better uses of its abilities, while wishing the experience were more consistent. The core is worth playing, but I do not find the Ultimate treatment enough to turn all of its mixed qualities into a uniformly excellent game.
The amusement-park idea is the strongest part of the presentation. Each area can have its own exaggerated attraction, letting the game change its scenery without losing the sense that the locations belong to the same strange place. I enjoy how the bright colors and large mechanical structures give movement a dramatic backdrop. The music supports that energy, and the remaster's updated presentation makes the settings attractive to revisit. The important question is how those places work as stages rather than how they look in isolation. A good section gives Sonic a route worth learning, with enough room for movement to feel satisfying instead of merely fast. Colors has those sections, and they are the main reason the game remains appealing. It also has stretches that feel less confident about their pace. The presentation makes the whole adventure inviting, while the actual rhythm of crossing it changes more in quality than I would like.

The Wisps give the game a useful way to change the interaction. A laser, a drill or a rocket can make part of a stage ask for a different action without sending the player into a completely separate campaign. I like that the abilities are connected to the environment. They can open a route, change the way an obstacle is understood or make another visit worthwhile once a new possibility is available. The limitation is how unevenly those changes fit the movement I enjoy most. Some powers feel like a welcome extension of the stage, while others interrupt the flow for an activity I am less eager to repeat. A new form is not automatically an improvement simply because it looks dramatic. I want the action it creates to be as enjoyable as the ordinary platforming around it. Colors reaches that point often enough to make the system worthwhile, but not consistently enough for every Wisp section to feel equally welcome.
The mix of two-dimensional and three-dimensional sections gives the adventure another source of variety. I like how the viewpoint can change the kind of route being read without changing the character's basic purpose. A focused side-on section can ask for more deliberate jumps, while a wider fast section can create a stronger impression of forward momentum. The best stages connect those approaches naturally. My reservation is that some slower platforming feels less graceful than the more exciting stretches suggest it should. A careful section can be good; I simply want it to feel comfortable and purposeful rather than like a pause before the game becomes lively again. That is a recurring qualification in my opinion. The adventure has enjoyable pieces, but their arrangement does not always create an equally satisfying overall pace. The variation is useful when the different parts reinforce one another, and weaker when the next change mainly reminds me which style I would rather be playing.
Collecting and replaying give the stages a practical reason to be more than a first trip toward the goal. I like noticing a route or an item that suggests another ability might make the return worthwhile. That kind of goal suits Sonic because a familiar level can become more enjoyable as its shape is understood. The extra challenges also provide a reason to improve the actual movement rather than only accumulate completion markers. The danger is that repeated visits expose the less enjoyable sections as clearly as they reveal another route. A collectible can make a return necessary without making it exciting. I find the replay most appealing when the stage itself is one I want to learn more closely, and less appealing when the objective sends me through a slower or less comfortable stretch again. The game has enough good stage work to support returning, but the optional goals do not remove the unevenness in the underlying adventure.

The remaster adds another set of ideas around that foundation, including customization and the Jade Ghost Wisp. I appreciate having a new way to interact with certain obstacles, and changing Sonic's appearance is a pleasant extra for someone interested in that kind of expression. These additions are supporting features rather than the reason I would recommend the game. Their value depends on the strength of Colors itself. A new ability can create another route or a different solution, but it cannot make every older section feel newly designed around it. The same is true of the updated music and presentation: they make the adventure attractive to experience again without automatically changing how much fun every part is to play. I like that the package tries to offer more than a simple visual reissue. I just do not find every change equally important, and the main recommendation remains the original adventure's stronger stages and most enjoyable uses of the Wisps.
I finish Colors Ultimate with a positive score and clear reservations. The setting is imaginative, the presentation has plenty of personality and the Wisp abilities give the platforming worthwhile changes of emphasis. Some stages are enjoyable enough to invite another attempt simply for the pleasure of handling them better. Other sections interrupt the pace or rely on an ability I find less satisfying to use. The remaster gives those qualities another home and adds useful extras without making the whole game equally convincing. Seven out of ten reflects an adventure I like rather than one I consider exceptional. I enjoy its colorful ideas and the better connections between movement and power use, while wishing the transitions between those moments were smoother and more consistently fun. It remains a worthwhile Sonic game, with an unevenness that the Ultimate title does not entirely overcome.
Final thoughts
Colors Ultimate retains an imaginative setting, enjoyable stages and worthwhile Wisp abilities. The slower sections and uneven use of those powers interrupt the pace, while the remaster's extras support the adventure without transforming it. I like the core more than every part of the complete package. 7/10.
Final score: 7/10.
Reviewed on PC. No review copy was provided.
Sonic Dash 2 Sonic Boom Review
Sonic Colors Wii Review
Sonic Colors DS Review