A Sonic RPG with a promising cast and painfully dull battles
Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood is a game whose premise interests me far more than the experience it delivers. A party RPG should give this cast room for abilities, conversations and a larger adventure without needing to imitate the platformers. I like that possibility. The finished DS game makes too much of the journey feel tedious, with battles that are less enjoyable than their touch-screen activity suggests and exploration that rarely becomes compelling enough to compensate. Two out of ten is my score. I am not disappointed simply because Sonic has stopped running through ordinary action stages. I am disappointed because the replacement does not provide a satisfying RPG of its own. Familiar characters and a different genre are not enough to carry weak pacing, unappealing encounters and a presentation that does little to make the repetition more inviting. The potential is obvious, but potential is not a good reason to keep working through another dull fight.
The party structure is the strongest part of the idea. Sonic's cast has enough different abilities and personalities to make a group adventure feel natural. Using a particular character to cross a gap, climb or reach a new part of an area gives exploration a clear connection to the roster. I like the thought of choosing who leads because that choice changes what can be done. The problem is how little excitement the actual traversal generates for me. Tapping a destination and following the route does not make moving around feel especially engaging, and the small obstacles rarely become an appealing puzzle in their own right. The abilities can be useful without making the environment interesting to explore. That distinction is where the promise begins to fade. I want the party's different strengths to open a world I am curious about, rather than act as another required switch before the next stretch of walking or the next battle can begin.

The combat is supposed to connect turn-based decisions with active timing, but I find the combination more tiring than rewarding. Choosing attacks and managing the party gives the encounters a familiar RPG framework. The stylus sequences then ask for attention while special moves are being carried out. I can appreciate the intention to keep the player involved rather than selecting commands and waiting. The activity itself is not enough to make the fight enjoyable. Repeating a touch pattern can become another piece of routine when the tactical decision around it is not compelling. I want the action input to deepen an attack I already care about. Too often it feels like extra work attached to another ordinary exchange. The system makes the battles busier without making them consistently more interesting, which is a serious weakness in a game that expects so much time to be spent moving from one encounter to the next.
POW moves and team attacks give the cast a practical identity, and I like the principle of abilities that require particular characters together. A Sonic and Tails combination should feel different from an individual attack, and the resource behind those moves gives the party something to manage beyond ordinary damage. The problem is the rhythm of the encounters. I do not find the next decision exciting enough to justify how much repeated input sits around it. A useful special attack can exist inside a battle system that still feels dull overall. That is my reaction here. I can identify individual mechanics that make sense, but they do not settle into a sequence I enjoy repeating. Equipment and character growth provide a reason to continue, yet the promise of a stronger party cannot make the current fight appealing by itself. I need the encounters to be enjoyable before their rewards can become an attractive reason to seek another one.
The Chao add another customization layer, giving collected creatures effects that can support a party member. I like using a familiar part of Sonic's world for something relevant to the RPG rather than leaving it as an unrelated extra. It is a sensible idea, and it gives the collecting a purpose. The larger problem remains the quality of the journey underneath the progression. Levels, equipment and Chao can all make a party more capable without making the act of using that party more fun. I find the game too dependent on those future rewards to hold attention through activities that are not satisfying enough in the present. The same is true of the exploration puzzles. Splitting up to handle switches gives the group a reason to act together, but the structure rarely becomes interesting enough to make me look forward to the next variation. There are several useful components here, yet the complete adventure feels much weaker than their separate descriptions suggest.

The story gives the game a larger scale, with familiar relationships and a threat that reaches beyond an ordinary set of zones. I like the idea of the cast having time to talk and react to one another within a party adventure. Some of that character appeal survives, which makes the rest more frustrating. The presentation does not help enough. The music and visual delivery do not give the environments or battles the energy I want, and the repeated structure makes it harder to remain interested in the next story step. A slower genre can still feel lively through strong atmosphere, engaging dialogue and satisfying encounters. Chronicles does not achieve that balance for me. I am more interested in what a Sonic RPG could do with these characters than in what this one actually asks me to carry out. The difference is substantial, and the familiarity of the cast makes it easier to see the missed opportunity rather than easier to ignore the weak play.
I finish at two out of ten because the disappointing parts are too central to treat as small qualifications. The battles are the core activity, and I do not enjoy their mixture of routine decisions and stylus work. The exploration uses character abilities sensibly without becoming an engaging world to navigate, while the progression and Chao systems provide rewards that cannot carry the experience on their own. I like the ambition to make a Sonic party RPG. I dislike how little enjoyment this particular attempt finds in that ambition. A genre change should be judged by the quality of the new game, and on those terms Chronicles falls badly short for me. It has ideas worth recognizing and a cast worth using better, but the finished adventure is dull, uneven and much more work than fun. I would rather see the premise tried properly again than recommend this execution as something its familiar characters make worthwhile.
Final thoughts
Chronicles has a sensible premise and useful ideas for party abilities, but its dull battles and repetitive stylus demands make the RPG exhausting rather than engaging. Exploration and progression do not compensate, and the presentation adds little energy. I like the possibility of a Sonic RPG far more than this game. 2/10.
Final score: 2/10.
Reviewed on Nintendo DS. No review copy was provided.

The Murder of Sonic the Hedgehog Review
LEGO Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight Review
Sonic at the Olympic Games Review