A dull team adventure whose extra mechanics never make the ordinary action enjoyable

Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyric is a game I find exhausting for the wrong reasons. It has a team of recognizable characters, several ways to move around and a bright adventure setting, but the ordinary work of crossing a space or clearing another fight is rarely enjoyable enough to support them. The slower approach is not automatically the problem. I would be happy with a Sonic game that values exploration and teamwork if those activities were satisfying. Here they too often feel like a series of uninteresting requirements placed between one part of the adventure and the next. Three out of ten is my score. The characterful idea of the Boom cast has some appeal, and the team abilities suggest a game that could have been worthwhile. The actual adventure does not make those suggestions feel convincing. I am left with a dull sequence of combat, collecting and prescribed interactions whose familiarity becomes tiring long before the journey has earned the attention it asks for.

The combat is the clearest example of that weakness. Sonic, Tails, Knuckles and Amy can attack enemies in different ways, but a useful difference between characters needs encounters that make the choice interesting. I do not find enough of that here. Too many fights feel like another group to clear rather than a situation I want to understand better. The action lacks the satisfying rhythm that would make repeating a basic move or switching to another approach enjoyable. A combat-heavy adventure can rely on familiar enemies if the act of fighting them feels good. Rise of Lyric instead makes me more aware of the number of encounters than the pleasure of their individual exchanges. I appreciate that the characters have been given more to do than run through a stage, but I would rather have fewer actions that work well than several options that fail to make an ordinary fight exciting. The feature is present; the enjoyment is what I find missing.

Sonic Boom Rise of Lyric game imagery 1

The character abilities create an obvious framework for teamwork. Tails' gadgets, Knuckles' climbing and digging, Amy's hammer-related movement and Sonic's familiar attacks give the cast reasons to be involved. I like the idea of a group whose different talents affect the route instead of simply appearing in dialogue. The problem is how prescribed those differences can feel. A particular obstacle often seems to exist mainly to request the appropriate character, making the interaction a small selection task rather than an interesting use of the environment. I want to think about what a character can do and see an enjoyable possibility in the space. I am much less enthusiastic when the game simply presents another recognizable requirement and waits for the expected response. The team system has a clear purpose, but that purpose is not consistently turned into satisfying play. It makes the cast necessary without making the act of using the cast especially rewarding.

The Enerbeam is another mechanic with a broad list of uses and too little appeal in the ordinary interaction. Pulling at enemies, moving along rails or engaging with a puzzle gives the device a place throughout the adventure. I appreciate the attempt to make one tool connect different activities. The trouble is that connecting weak activities does not automatically make the tool interesting. A prompt to use the beam can become another small interruption rather than a welcome change of pace. I would enjoy a system that let movement and combat flow into each other through the same action. Here I am more often aware of the next required use than excited by the possibility it creates. The game has plenty of things that can be described as mechanics, but a list of mechanics is not the same as a good adventure. The important question is whether carrying out the next action is enjoyable, and the beam does not answer that question strongly enough.

The level structure makes the repetition harder to ignore. Slower exploration, collecting and fights sit alongside faster sections, but the changes do not create a dependable rhythm. A burst of speed can make the game more lively for a moment, then the adventure returns to another space whose main interest seems to be the work needed to move past it. I do not object to a slower stage or a collecting goal by itself. I object to how little curiosity the next area produces. An adventure should make the environment feel worth looking through, whether because the movement is enjoyable, the discovery is useful or the setting is particularly interesting. Rise of Lyric has attractive pieces of scenery without consistently making those pieces rewarding to negotiate. The result is a game that can feel busy and empty at the same time: there are several things to do, but too few of them provide a compelling reason to care about doing them.

Sonic Boom Rise of Lyric game imagery 2

The cast and presentation are the parts I can appreciate without liking the game. The Boom versions of the characters have recognizable personalities, and the group dynamic gives the story room for lighthearted exchanges. I enjoy the intention to make the adventure feel like a team outing rather than another solitary run toward Eggman. The visual style also has a clear identity, with colorful settings that look as though they should support a more playful journey. That is what makes the dullness of the action so disappointing. The cast can give a scene a little charm, but it cannot make another repetitive fight or prescribed traversal step suddenly satisfying. I would rather have the character work supporting enjoyable play than doing the job of keeping an uninteresting sequence tolerable. Lyric provides a new threat, yet the story does little to change my reaction to the ordinary route. The world invites interest more successfully than the game rewards it.

My final score stays at three because the weaknesses are central rather than isolated. The combat is dull, the team abilities are too often reduced to prescribed uses and the exploration rarely makes the next space feel worth investigating. The faster sections and the charm of the cast are not enough to carry the long stretches around them. I can appreciate what a cooperative Sonic adventure might offer without finding this version of that idea worthwhile. Rise of Lyric repeatedly adds another task where I want a more enjoyable action. That difference shapes the whole experience. I do not need the game to imitate the main series exactly, and I am not rejecting the slower format simply for being different. I am rejecting how little pleasure it produces from the things it chooses to emphasize. The result is a disappointing adventure whose recognizable characters and several mechanics cannot hide the weak interaction underneath them.

Final thoughts

Rise of Lyric makes its team necessary without making combat, exploration or traversal enjoyable enough. The cast has some charm, but prescribed abilities and repetitive encounters leave the adventure dull. I like the possibility of a different Sonic format much more than this execution of it. 3/10.

Final score: 3/10.

Reviewed on Nintendo Wii U. No review copy was provided.