A striking storybook Sonic that needs too much patience before its movement becomes enjoyable

Sonic and the Secret Rings has an identity I like immediately. The Arabian Nights setting gives the adventure a fresh mood, and the idea of a forward-running Sonic game built around the Wii Remote is easy to understand. The stronger stages can make the motion steering and spectacle work together, giving the journey an energy distinct from the ordinary three-dimensional games. The problem is how much frustration sits around those moments. The movement can feel restrictive, the early abilities do not make the best impression and the mission structure repeats areas in ways I do not always enjoy. Six out of ten is my score. I appreciate the setting and several of the ideas enough to find the game worthwhile, but the complete experience asks for more patience than I want to give it. It is an appealing experiment whose presentation is more consistently convincing than the ordinary act of moving through its stages.

The fixed forward route changes what Sonic's movement means. Instead of freely choosing where to run in a broad environment, the main task is to steer, brake, jump and react along the path. I like the clarity that can provide when the level communicates its next demand well. The game can concentrate on a dramatic sequence without worrying about every direction the character might choose to explore. The limitation is the feeling of being constrained when a correction is needed. A missed object or an awkward approach is much less comfortable to deal with when the game has already committed to moving along its route. That makes the difference between a clean run and a frustrating one especially noticeable. I enjoy the best forward sections as their own kind of Sonic, but I do not think the restriction excuses the places where the movement becomes fussy. The chosen structure needs to make its limits feel purposeful rather than simply inconvenient.

Sonic and the Secret Rings game imagery 1

Motion steering gives the game its main physical character. Tilting the horizontally held Wii Remote is a different kind of action from guiding Sonic with a stick, and I like the attempt to build the stages around that difference. It can feel immediate when the route asks for a broad adjustment that is easy to understand. The jump and homing-attack demands are less consistently comfortable, especially when several actions arrive close together. I do not find the input equally well suited to every kind of obstacle. A control idea can work in one stretch and still be a poor match for the next demand. That is how much of Secret Rings feels to me. The game is at its strongest when it understands the sort of movement the controller makes enjoyable. It is weaker when it asks for a degree of correction or a repeated maneuver that exposes how little freedom the system offers compared with a more direct way of moving Sonic.

The skill system makes that mixed introduction more complicated. Experience and unlockable abilities give the game a substantial progression layer, and I like being able to configure Sonic for a particular set of demands. A useful upgrade can make a familiar route more comfortable or open another way to approach a challenge. The problem is how much basic enjoyment seems tied to improving the setup first. I want the initial movement to make a strong case for the game, with later skills adding possibilities rather than making the early version feel like something to tolerate. The different skill rings also mean there is another layer to consider before a mission can begin. That can be interesting when the choice supports a clear strategy. It is less appealing when I mainly want the character to feel better at the ordinary actions the stage already requires. The progression has a purpose, but its pacing does not always serve the adventure's immediate pleasure.

The missions give the environments more than one use, yet they are another source of uneven pacing. A familiar stage can become interesting again when a new objective changes how it is read or which action matters most. I like that possibility more than repeating a route under a condition that mainly makes it less comfortable. A large selection of missions does not automatically provide a large selection of enjoyable experiences. The game sometimes feels too satisfied with changing the requirement while leaving the same awkward interaction underneath it. Speed Break and Time Break provide more dramatic tools, and I enjoy the way they can change the rhythm of a section. They are appealing additions to the storybook fantasy. They do not make every mission worth revisiting, especially when the route has already shown most of what makes it interesting and the new demand only stretches the effort needed to reach the next part of the adventure.

Sonic and the Secret Rings game imagery 2

The setting remains the game's most consistent strength. The storybook presentation, environments and music give it a strong personality, and I like seeing Sonic placed in a world that invites a different kind of adventure without losing his recognizable attitude. The dramatic setup is more appealing to me than another generic excuse to run through familiar zones. It makes the stronger stages feel like part of something with its own mood. The supporting extras also reflect a willingness to give the package more than a short main path, though the party activities are not what would make me recommend it. My interest stays with the central storybook journey and the moments when its movement is enjoyable. The appearance and music make me want those moments to be more consistent. They cannot make an awkward mission feel good simply because the surrounding world is attractive or because the next scene might provide another reason to care.

I finish Secret Rings with a mixed recommendation at six out of ten. Its setting is memorable, the forward-running structure can produce exciting stages and the skill choices offer some useful ways to change the action. The motion controls, restricted corrections and repetitive mission demands keep the experience from becoming consistently satisfying. I like enough of the game to value the experiment, but not enough to overlook how much effort it takes to reach and maintain its better rhythm. A more comfortable starting setup and a tighter selection of missions would have made the same premise much stronger. As it stands, the storybook has more charm than the complete play experience has polish. I enjoy visiting its world, while wishing the process of moving through that world were less likely to turn an appealing idea into another small test of patience before the next enjoyable stage can begin.

Final thoughts

Secret Rings has a memorable setting and some exciting forward-running stages. The motion input, restrictive corrections and uneven skill progression make the journey less comfortable than it should be, while repeated missions stretch the weaker parts. I like the storybook idea more consistently than the complete Wii game. 6/10.

Final score: 6/10.

Reviewed on Nintendo Wii. No review copy was provided.