An attractive winter party with good events buried in an uneven sporting collection

Mario & Sonic at the Sochi 2014 Olympic Winter Games has a pleasant winter atmosphere and enough entertaining events to make it worthwhile, but I do not find the whole package especially consistent. The characters and snowy settings are easy to enjoy, and the better disciplines turn a small action into a satisfying challenge. The weaker ones feel less substantial, while the mix of controller requirements makes the experience fussier than a quick sports party should be. Six and a half is my score. I like the idea of giving Mario and Sonic another lively sporting occasion, and the Dream Events provide some of the strongest reasons for this crossover to exist. I am less convinced by how evenly the game maintains that appeal across its modes and events. It is a collection with favorites worth returning to rather than a winter-sports package whose entire selection keeps me equally interested.

The ordinary events provide a clear foundation. Skiing, skating, curling and the other disciplines have understandable goals, so a short attempt can produce a result that is easy to compare and improve. I like that immediate purpose. A sports collection does not need to spend a long time explaining why reaching the finish faster or placing something more accurately matters. The characters make those familiar tasks more playful, which suits the intended mood. My reservation is that the translation into small controller actions is uneven. Some disciplines have a useful sense of timing or direction, while others feel more like carrying out an input sequence than learning a satisfying sport. The collection is strongest when the control makes sense as part of the event. It is weaker when the gesture or controller choice seems to be the main novelty, leaving the sporting action itself with less depth than its presentation suggests.

Mario & Sonic at the Sochi 2014 Olympic Winter Games game imagery 1

The use of Wii Remote Plus and the GamePad gives the package more than one way to approach an event. I can appreciate the attempt to make a different discipline feel different in the hands rather than forcing everything into an identical control scheme. The problem is the friction that can create around a collection meant to be approachable. Switching between approaches adds another thing to understand before the next short competition begins, and the benefit is not equally convincing in every activity. I like a controller feature when it makes an action clearer or more enjoyable. I am less interested when it mainly makes the event feel more particular about how it has to be played. Sochi has worthwhile uses of its hardware, but the range does not automatically make the whole package more intuitive. The best controls disappear into the sporting goal; the weaker ones make me more aware of the equipment than the competition.

The Dream Events are the more imaginative side of the selection. Bringing the worlds of Mario and Sonic into the rules gives the crossover a purpose beyond a familiar roster performing standard disciplines. I enjoy a winter activity becoming something more playful through its setting and obstacles. A mixed race with different forms of winter movement is an appealing example of the game finding a reason to be fanciful rather than realistic. The important part is that the change affects the activity, not only the scenery. My enthusiasm is still selective. A Dream Event can be inventive without being especially satisfying to repeat, and I do not find every one equally successful. The group helps the package considerably, though. It gives Sochi some personality that would be missing if it were only a series of simplified Olympic disciplines, and it makes the strongest events more memorable than their short duration might otherwise allow.

Legends Showdown gives the solo side a more connected sequence to work through, which I appreciate as an alternative to repeatedly choosing isolated events. A collection can feel more substantial when there is a clear progression through its activities rather than only a menu. The limitation is that a connecting structure still depends on the quality of the events it connects. Moving toward the next stage of the mode does not make a less enjoyable discipline suddenly compelling. The Action & Answer Tour takes another approach by mixing competition with questions, adding a party framework that is distinct from simply improving a time or score. I like the intention to offer different ways of using the same collection. I am less convinced that every added layer improves the pace. Sometimes I would rather reach a favorite event directly than follow another sequence of small transitions that adds structure without adding much enjoyment to the actual sport.

Mario & Sonic at the Sochi 2014 Olympic Winter Games game imagery 2

The presentation is consistently inviting. The snowy settings, expressive characters and event animations give the game a cheerful identity, while the improved visual detail makes the sporting occasion feel lively. I like the cast's different attitudes and the way an unlikely competitor can make an ordinary event amusing to watch. Those qualities matter in a lighthearted collection. They cannot make every control scheme or event rule equally appealing, though. I am more likely to return because a particular discipline feels good than because its celebration animation is charming. The game gives me enough of both to keep the opinion positive, but the balance is uneven. Its appearance promises a smooth party experience more often than the whole selection delivers one. I can appreciate the visual care while still wishing the ordinary transition from choosing an event to enjoying it were less fussy and more consistently rewarding. The strongest activities deserve the attractive setting more than the weaker ones do.

I finish with a measured recommendation. Sochi 2014 has worthwhile winter events, imaginative Dream variations and a presentation that makes the crossover pleasant to spend time with. The uneven controls, variable depth and less appealing connecting modes keep it from becoming a stronger package. Six and a half out of ten reflects a collection I can enjoy through its better activities without wanting to endorse every part of the menu. I do not need a Mario and Sonic sports game to be a demanding simulation. I do need its short competitions to be satisfying and easy enough to approach that the party atmosphere survives the control requirements. This one reaches that standard often enough to remain worthwhile, but misses it often enough that the qualifications matter. The winter setting gives it charm, while the inconsistency of the actual events leaves the complete experience less convincing than a few of its favorites.

Final thoughts

Sochi has an appealing winter presentation and several enjoyable events, especially when the Dream variations use the crossover creatively. The controls and depth vary too much across the selection, while the extra modes do not always improve the pace. A worthwhile but uneven sports collection. 6.5/10.

Final score: 6.5/10.

Reviewed on Nintendo Wii U. No review copy was provided.